SN7
SHORT NOTE
5M
Describe the injuries of the spine and their medicolegal importance.
Mechanism and Types
- Mechanisms of spinal injury — hyperflexion (the commonest, from a blow to the back of the head or a fall on the flexed neck), producing anterior wedge compression and posterior ligament rupture; hyperextension (a blow to the face or forehead, or a rear-end collision), producing anterior ligament rupture and, in the elderly with cervical spondylosis, central cord injury without any fracture; axial compression (a fall on the head, feet or buttocks, or diving into shallow water), producing burst fractures; rotation, producing unstable fracture-dislocation; and distraction, as in judicial hanging
- The cord may be injured without any radiological fracture — sciwora (spinal cord injury without radiographic abnormality), particularly in children, whose elastic spine allows the cord to be stretched and released without bony injury; and in the elderly with a stenotic canal
| Region and level | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Above C4 | Phrenic nerve (C3, C4, C5) is involved — respiratory paralysis and death unless ventilated. "C3, 4 and 5 keep the diaphragm alive" |
| C5 to C8 | Quadriplegia with the diaphragm preserved; survival possible |
| Cervical injury generally | Neurogenic shock — loss of sympathetic tone giving hypotension with bradycardia, which distinguishes it from hypovolaemic shock where the pulse is fast; and poikilothermia |
| Thoracic | Paraplegia; the thoracic spine is stable, so a fracture there implies severe force |
| Thoracolumbar junction (T12–L1) | The commonest site of thoracolumbar injury, being the junction of the rigid thoracic and mobile lumbar spine; conus medullaris syndrome |
| Below L1 | Cauda equina syndrome — a lower motor neurone lesion with saddle anaesthesia and sphincter disturbance; a surgical emergency |
| Atlanto-axial and odontoid | Fracture of the odontoid process, and atlanto-axial dislocation — immediately fatal if the cord is transected. Occurs in judicial hanging, and in falls in the elderly |
CLINICAL PEARL
Neurogenic shock is hypotension with a slow pulse, and that single fact prevents a fatal error. Every other form of shock in a trauma patient gives tachycardia, so an injured, hypotensive patient with a bradycardia has lost sympathetic tone from a cervical cord injury — not blood. Filling them with fluid does not correct it and may cause pulmonary oedema; they need vasopressors and the cord protecting.
Whiplash and Special Injuries
- Whiplash injury — sudden hyperextension followed by hyperflexion of the neck, characteristically in a rear-end collision. It injures the cervical soft tissues, muscles and ligaments, producing pain and stiffness developing over hours; and in severe cases the cervical cord and brain stem, which may cause death with minimal external injury. It is a very common subject of compensation claims, and the difficulty is that the injury is largely subjective and imaging is often normal
- Injury from shaking an infant, in which the same mechanism damages the cervicomedullary junction
- Judicial hanging — the drop produces fracture-dislocation of the upper cervical spine with transection of the cord ("hangman's fracture" of the pars interarticularis of C2), causing immediate death
- Diving into shallow water — axial compression producing a burst fracture of the mid-cervical spine, a classical accidental mechanism
- Movement of an injured spine may convert a stable injury into a cord transection, which is why immobilisation precedes everything else and why careless handling at the scene is itself a cause of paralysis
Medicolegal Aspects and Applied Aspects
- Spinal injury is almost always grievous hurt — under the eighth clause as endangering life or disabling the person for twenty days, and usually under the fifth as permanently impairing the powers of a member
- The questions asked — the mechanism, and whether it fits the account given; whether the injury was accidental, suicidal or homicidal; the extent of permanent disability for compensation; and whether the handling after the injury contributed, which raises a question of negligence
- Immobilise the spine at the scene in any suspected injury, and do not move the patient without it; converting an incomplete injury into a complete one by careless movement is a real and recurring cause of avoidable paralysis
- Suspect a cervical injury in every unconscious trauma patient and in anyone with head or facial injury; the patient cannot complain of neck pain and the injury is missed
- Remember sciwora in children; a normal radiograph does not exclude cord injury, and magnetic resonance imaging is required where the signs are present
- Recognise neurogenic shock by the bradycardia and treat it with vasopressors rather than unlimited fluid, while excluding concurrent haemorrhage
- Examine the spinal cord at autopsy where the mechanism suggests it; the cord is not removed routinely, and a cervical injury may be entirely missed if the posterior approach is not used
- Document disability carefully for compensation — the level, the completeness, the sphincter function and the prognosis — since the award depends on it and the assessment may be revisited years later
All questions in Regional Injuries & Physical Agents
- Q1Describe the injuries of the scalp and the fractures of the skull with their medicolegal importance. ★
- Q2Describe the intracranial haemorrhages and brain injuries. Add a note on coup and contrecoup injury. ★
- Q3Describe the injuries of the chest and abdomen with their medicolegal importance. ★
- Q4Describe burns and scalds with their classification, causes of death and medicolegal aspects. ★
- Q5Describe the injuries and death caused by electricity. Add a note on lightning. ★
- SN1Describe dowry death and bride burning with the legal provisions. ★
- SN2Describe corrosive injuries and the medicolegal aspects of acid attacks. ★
- SN3Describe heat cramps, heat exhaustion and heat stroke. ★
- SN4Describe hypothermia and the local effects of cold. ★
- SN5Describe radiation injuries and their medicolegal importance. ★
- SN6Describe the recognition of child abuse and abusive head trauma. ★
- SN7Describe the injuries of the spine and their medicolegal importance.