Describe burns and scalds with their classification, causes of death and medicolegal aspects.
Definitions and Classification
A burn is an injury caused by the application of dry heat, flame, a heated solid, or by chemicals, electricity or radiation. A scald is an injury caused by moist heat — hot liquid or steam.
| Feature | Burn (dry heat) | Scald (moist heat) |
|---|---|---|
| Cause | Flame, heated solid, dry heat | Hot liquid or steam |
| Site | Anywhere; the shape corresponds to the object | Follows gravity — runs downward in streaks and trickles from the point of contact, which is highly characteristic |
| Margins | Irregular and less well defined | Well defined; a "splash" pattern with satellite lesions |
| Hair | Singed — the single most useful discriminator | Not singed |
| Clothing | Burnt or charred | Wet and stained but not burnt |
| Charring | Present in severe burns | Never — scalds do not char, since water cannot exceed 100°C |
| Blisters | Present | Present, and often more prominent |
| Depth | May be full thickness and deeper | Rarely full thickness; usually superficial to partial thickness |
| Depth | Features |
|---|---|
| Superficial (first degree, epidermal) | Erythema only, painful, blanching; heals in days without a scar. Sunburn |
| Partial thickness (second degree, dermo-epidermal) | Blisters; very painful because nerve endings are exposed; heals in 2 to 3 weeks with little or no scarring if superficial, and with scarring if deep |
| Full thickness (third degree, deep) | The whole dermis destroyed; dry, leathery, white or charred; painless and insensitive because the nerve endings are destroyed — a paradox worth remembering, since the deepest burn hurts least. Requires grafting and heals with contracture |
| Fourth degree | Extending into muscle, tendon and bone; charring |
- The historical classifications remain examinable — dupuytren'S six degrees and WILSON'S three-fold division into epidermal, dermo-epidermal and deep
- Extent is estimated by the rule OF nine (wallace) in adults — head and neck 9%, each upper limb 9%, each lower limb 18%, front of trunk 18%, back of trunk 18%, and perineum 1%. The palm of the patient's own hand is about 1%, which is a practical way of measuring scattered burns
- The rule of nine is inaccurate IN children, whose head is proportionately much larger and limbs smaller; the LUND and browder chart is used instead and corrects for age
- Prognosis — broadly, burns over one-third of the body surface are dangerous to life and over 50 to 60% usually fatal, though modern burn care has improved this; extremes of age, inhalational injury, full-thickness burns and delay in treatment all worsen it
CLINICAL PEARL
The deepest burn is the one that does not hurt. A full-thickness burn destroys the nerve endings, so it is insensitive, while a partial thickness burn leaves them exposed and is agonising. A patient with a dry, white, painless area therefore has a worse injury than one with painful blisters — and testing sensation with a needle is a bedside way of assessing depth that costs nothing.
Causes of Death and Antemortem Burns
- Immediate (within hours) — primary neurogenic shock from pain and fright; asphyxia from laryngeal oedema and inhalation of hot gases; and carbon monoxide poisoning, which is the commonest cause of death in a house or vehicle fire and often kills before any significant burning
- Early (first few days) — secondary (hypovolaemic) shock from massive plasma loss through the burned surface; and acute renal failure
- Delayed (after the first week) — infection and septicaemia, which is the commonest cause of death overall in those who survive the first days, with Pseudomonas, Staphylococcus and Klebsiella; curling'S ulcer of the duodenum with haemorrhage or perforation; acute respiratory distress syndrome; pulmonary embolism; and multi-organ failure
- Late — contractures and disfigurement, and rarely malignant change (Marjolin's ulcer) in a chronic scar
| Feature | Antemortem burn | Postmortem burn |
|---|---|---|
| Line of redness (hyperaemic zone) | Present — a red line of demarcation at the margin, a true vital reaction. It appears within an hour and is the classical sign | Absent |
| Blister contents | Fluid rich in albumin and chlorides; the base is red and inflamed; heat coagulates protein so the fluid is proteinaceous | Contains mainly air with little fluid; the base is dry, hard and yellow |
| Soot in the air passages below the larynx | Present — proves the person was breathing in the fire. The single most valuable sign | Absent, or only in the mouth and upper airway |
| Carboxyhaemoglobin in the blood | Raised — typically above 10%, and often far higher. Also proves the person was alive and breathing. Lividity is cherry-pink | Not raised |
| Histology | Inflammatory infiltration, vital reaction, and later healing | None |
| Healing / suppuration | Present if survival was long enough | Never |
- Soot below the larynx and a raised carboxyhaemoglobin are the two findings that settle the question, and both should be sought in every fire death; a body burnt after death shows neither, which indicates that death preceded the fire and the true cause lies elsewhere
- Heat artefacts must not be mistaken for injuries — the pugilistic attitude, a flexed "boxer" posture from heat coagulation of muscle, occurring whether the person was alive or dead; heat ruptures and skin splits resembling lacerations or incised wounds, which have no vital reaction and occur along lines of tension; heat fractures of the skull; and the heat haematoma, a chocolate-brown, honeycombed extradural collection on the side exposed to heat, with NO skull fracture and no scalp injury, which mimics a traumatic extradural haematoma
Examination of a Burnt Body
Preserve the clothing and any residue for identification of an accelerant; note the smell of kerosene or petrol before the body is washed → Estimate the surface area and depth of burning, and record the distribution — front or back, upper or lower body — which bears directly on the manner → Look for the red line of demarcation at the margins and examine the blister contents — the vital reactions → Open the airway and look for soot below the larynx, recording how far down it extends; and take blood for carboxyhaemoglobin and cyanide before anything else → Search beneath the burns for injuries the fire cannot explain — the neck structures and hyoid, the scalp, and any fracture or stab wound → Distinguish the heat artefacts — pugilistic attitude, heat ruptures, heat fractures and heat haematoma — and state that they are artefacts → Preserve viscera for toxicology, since a sedative or poison may have been given first → Establish identity — teeth, radiographs and DNA, since the features are usually destroyed
Manner and Applied Aspects
- Accidental burns are much the commonest in India — kitchen accidents with kerosene stoves and open fires, loose synthetic clothing and the dupatta or sari catching fire, and children scalded by hot liquids
- Suicidal — self-immolation, usually with kerosene poured over the head and shoulders so the burns are extensive and involve the front and the head; a container may be present; and the person is usually alone with the doors closed
- Homicidal — dowry-related bride burning, and the burning of a body to conceal a homicide; suggested by injuries not explained by the fire, absence of soot and carboxyhaemoglobin, and evidence of restraint
- Always perform a complete autopsy and take blood for carboxyhaemoglobin, cyanide and alcohol, and preserve viscera; the question of whether the person was alive when the fire began is the central issue in every such case
- Examine the airway for soot down to the bronchi, and record the level reached; and examine the burnt body fully, since the trunk cavities are often well preserved beneath charred skin
- Record a dying declaration where the person is conscious, with certification of mental fitness before and after; in burns cases this is frequently the only direct evidence, and extensive burns do not by themselves make a person unfit
- Do not report the pugilistic attitude as a defensive posture or a heat rupture as a laceration; these artefacts have led to entirely wrong reconstructions
- Scalds never char and burns singe hair; these two features separate moist from dry heat more reliably than anything else
- The rule of nine is wrong in children, whose head is proportionately far larger; use the Lund and Browder chart, or the palm-equals-one-percent rule for scattered burns
- Septicaemia is the commonest cause of death overall in those who survive the first days, which makes burn units an infection-control problem before anything else
- A heat haematoma has no fracture and no scalp injury, is chocolate-brown and honeycombed, and lies on the side exposed to the fire — which separates it from a traumatic extradural
- Estimate the surface area before the burns are dressed; once covered, the assessment cannot be repeated and the figure drives both the treatment and the medicolegal opinion
- Take carboxyhaemoglobin and cyanide in every fire death; both are produced by burning household materials, and both prove the person was breathing
- Blister fluid rich in albumin and chloride means antemortem; air with a dry yellow base means the blister formed after death
- Full-thickness burns are painless, so testing sensation is a bedside way of assessing depth and a painless white area is the worse injury
- Curling ulcer causes late haemorrhage in a burns patient and should be considered in any gastrointestinal bleed after burns
- Kerosene stove accidents remain the commonest cause in India, and the distinction from bride burning rests on the distribution, the injuries beneath and the circumstances
- Look for injuries beneath the burns — the neck structures, hyoid and scalp — since strangulation followed by burning is the characteristic homicidal pattern
All questions in Regional Injuries & Physical Agents
- Q1Describe the injuries of the scalp and the fractures of the skull with their medicolegal importance. ★
- Q2Describe the intracranial haemorrhages and brain injuries. Add a note on coup and contrecoup injury. ★
- Q3Describe the injuries of the chest and abdomen with their medicolegal importance. ★
- Q4Describe burns and scalds with their classification, causes of death and medicolegal aspects. ★
- Q5Describe the injuries and death caused by electricity. Add a note on lightning. ★
- SN1Describe dowry death and bride burning with the legal provisions. ★
- SN2Describe corrosive injuries and the medicolegal aspects of acid attacks. ★
- SN3Describe heat cramps, heat exhaustion and heat stroke. ★
- SN4Describe hypothermia and the local effects of cold. ★
- SN5Describe radiation injuries and their medicolegal importance. ★
- SN6Describe the recognition of child abuse and abusive head trauma. ★
- SN7Describe the injuries of the spine and their medicolegal importance.