Q3
LONG ANSWER
10M
★ High-yield
Describe lacerated, incised and stab wounds and distinguish between them.
Lacerated Wounds
A laceration is a tear or split of the skin and underlying tissues produced by blunt force, in which the tissue is crushed, stretched or torn rather than cut.
| Type | Mechanism and example |
|---|---|
| Split laceration | Crushing of the skin between the weapon and underlying bone — the scalp, eyebrow, cheek bone, iliac crest and shin. This is the type most often mistaken for AN incised wound, because over bone the margins may look deceptively clean |
| Stretch laceration | Overstretching of the skin, as when a limb is run over or a bone fractured and the fragment tears the skin from within |
| Avulsion | Separation of the skin from underlying tissue by a grinding or shearing force — a vehicle wheel; "flaying" or "degloving" of a limb |
| Tear laceration | From an irregular projecting object — a door handle, a broken bone end, or a projection on a moving vehicle |
| Cut (chop) laceration | From a heavy weapon with a relatively blunt edge |
| Feature | Lacerated wound | Incised wound |
|---|---|---|
| Causative weapon | Blunt | Sharp-edged |
| Margins | Irregular, ragged, abraded and contused, often inverted | Clean-cut, regular, everted, not abraded or contused |
| Tissue bridges across the depth | Present — strands of vessels, nerves and connective tissue crossing the floor, because they are more resistant than the surrounding tissue and are stretched rather than divided. This is the single most reliable distinguishing feature | Absent — everything is divided cleanly at the same level |
| Hair at the margin | Hair bulbs crushed but hair not cut — the follicles are torn out intact | Hair cleanly cut at the margin |
| Dimensions | Depth variable and irregular; wound gapes irregularly | Length exceeds depth; wound gapes in a regular spindle shape from elastic retraction |
| Bleeding | Less — vessels are crushed and retract, so they thrombose | Profuse — vessels are cleanly divided and cannot retract |
| Foreign material | Grit, dirt, glass, paint and hair are commonly present in the depths | Usually absent |
| Healing | Slow, with infection common; heals with an irregular scar | Rapid; heals with a linear scar |
CLINICAL PEARL
Tissue bridges settle the question, and a scalp split will fool you otherwise. A blow to the scalp with a rod crushes the skin against the skull and produces a wound whose margins can look almost clean — and it is regularly certified as an incised wound, converting a beating into a stabbing. Retract the margins and look into the floor: strands of vessel and connective tissue crossing the depth mean blunt force, whatever the edges look like.
Incised Wounds
- Definition — a clean cut through the tissues produced by drawing a sharp-edged weapon across the skin, in which the length exceeds the depth
- Shape — spindle-shaped (elliptical) when gaping, because of the elastic retraction of the divided skin; the gaping is greatest when the wound runs across the LANGER lines and least when parallel to them, so the degree of gaping reflects the direction of the cut rather than the force used
- Direction of the cut is shown by tailing — the wound is deeper at the point of commencement and becomes shallower, ending in a superficial "tail" at the termination, because pressure is greatest at the start and is released as the weapon is drawn away
- Bleeding is profuse, and the wound may be fatal from haemorrhage even when small, particularly in the neck
- Chop wounds — produced by a heavy weapon with a sharp-ish edge: an axe, a hatchet, a sword, a chopper or a heavy daab. They combine features of both: the margins are cut but also bruised and abraded, the wound is deep, and there is characteristically an underlying fracture of bone with a corresponding cut or notch, which may retain a toolmark identifying the weapon
Stab (punctured) Wounds
- Definition — a wound produced by the penetration of a pointed weapon, in which the depth exceeds the length and breadth
- Weapons — a knife or dagger; and also a screwdriver, nail, scissors, needle, arrow, spear, glass fragment or any pointed object
- The shape of the skin wound reflects the weapon — a single-edged blade produces a wound with one sharp and one blunt (rounded or squared, "fish-tail") angle; a double-edged blade produces both angles sharp; a cylindrical weapon such as a nail produces a rounded or slit-like wound; and a screwdriver or square-sectioned instrument produces a characteristic cruciate or rectangular defect
- The shape is altered by Langer lines, so a single stab may gape into an ellipse and mislead; the wound should be approximated and then measured, and the true dimensions recorded
- Depth of the wound and length of the blade — the depth of the track is not necessarily the length of the blade. It may be greater, where the abdominal or chest wall was compressed on impact; or less, where the weapon was not fully inserted. So the doctor may state a minimum blade length and give the width from the wound, but cannot state the blade length precisely
- The direction of the track is recorded in three dimensions from the skin surface — upward or downward, medial or lateral, front to back — with the body in the anatomical position, and it may indicate the relative positions of assailant and victim
- Multiple stab wounds favour homicide; and a stab wound may be fatal from haemorrhage, from injury to a vital organ, from air embolism (neck veins), or from pneumothorax
Determining the Weapon and the Direction
| Question | What the wound shows |
|---|---|
| Blunt or sharp weapon? | Tissue bridges, abraded contused margins and crushed hair bulbs indicate blunt; clean margins, no bridges and cleanly cut hair indicate sharp |
| Single- or double-edged blade? | One sharp and one blunt or "fish-tail" angle indicates single-edged; both angles sharp indicates double-edged |
| Width of the blade? | The length of the stab wound after the margins are approximated — not as it gapes |
| Length of the blade? | A minimum only, from the depth of the track. The track may be deeper than the blade where the body wall was compressed, or shorter where the weapon was not fully inserted |
| Direction of an incised wound? | Tailing — deeper at the commencement, tapering to a superficial tail at the termination |
| Direction of an abrasion? | Epidermal tags heaped at the far (terminal) end |
| Direction of a stab track? | Recorded in three planes from the skin surface with the body in the anatomical position — upward or downward, medial or lateral, front to back |
| Was great force used? | Cannot be estimated from a stab wound — a sharp blade penetrates the chest or abdomen with very little force. Force can be inferred only from bone injury and crushing |
| Which weapon among several produced? | The wound is consistent with a class of weapon; only a toolmark on bone or cartilage can approach identifying an individual weapon |
Applied Aspects
- Look into the depth of every wound for tissue bridges before calling it incised; the scalp, eyebrow and shin produce split lacerations that look cut, and the distinction changes the weapon and therefore the case
- Photograph and describe before suturing in the living; once the wound is repaired its character is gone permanently, and a surgeon who sutures first should be asked to describe what was seen
- Record the angles of a stab wound, and approximate the margins before measuring; the number of sharp angles indicates whether the blade was single- or double-edged
- State the blade length as a minimum, never as a figure; compression of the body wall allows a track deeper than the blade, and this is a standard cross-examination point
- Look for an underlying bone injury in a chop wound; the notch may retain a toolmark that identifies the individual weapon, and it should be preserved rather than sawn through
- Do not estimate the force used from the depth of a stab; a sharp blade penetrates the chest or abdomen with very little force, and courts are repeatedly told otherwise
- The degree of gaping reflects the Langer lines, not the force; a wound across the lines gapes widely and one parallel to them barely at all
- Incised wounds bleed profusely and lacerations less, because crushed vessels retract and thrombose while cleanly divided ones cannot — which explains why a small neck incision can be rapidly fatal
- Preserve the bone in a chop wound rather than sawing through the notch; the toolmark may identify the individual weapon
- Approximate the margins before measuring a stab wound; the gaping dimension is not the width of the blade
- Look for foreign material in the depths of a laceration — grit, glass, paint, hair — which may link the wound to a particular surface or vehicle
- Give the blade length as a minimum only; compression of the chest or abdomen allows a track deeper than the weapon, and this is a standard cross-examination point
All questions in Mechanical Injuries
- Q1Define injury and hurt. Classify mechanical injuries and describe grievous hurt with the relevant legal provisions. ★
- Q2Describe abrasions and contusions with their types, ageing and medicolegal importance. ★
- Q3Describe lacerated, incised and stab wounds and distinguish between them. ★
- Q4Describe firearm injuries with the features of entry and exit wounds and the estimation of range. ★
- Q5Describe the medicolegal examination of wounds — antemortem and postmortem, ageing, manner of infliction and causes of death. ★
- SN1Describe defence wounds and hesitation cuts with their medicolegal importance. ★
- SN2Describe explosion and blast injuries. ★
- SN3Describe the injuries in road traffic accidents in pedestrians and vehicle occupants. ★
- SN4Describe the immediate and delayed causes of death from wounds. ★
- SN5Describe the medicolegal aspects of torture and custodial injuries. ★
- SN6Describe the injuries sustained in a fall from a height. ★
- SN7Describe the healing of wounds and the determination of the age of an injury.