SN4
SHORT NOTE
5M
★ High-yield
Describe the immediate and delayed causes of death from wounds.
Immediate Causes
| Cause | Mechanism and features |
|---|---|
| Haemorrhage — the commonest | Loss of about one-third of the blood volume (1.5 to 2 litres in an adult) rapidly is usually fatal; slower loss is tolerated better. May be external, or concealed internal — into the chest, abdomen, retroperitoneum, pelvis or thigh, where litres may be lost with NO external sign. Findings: pallor of the skin and organs, poorly developed or absent lividity, an empty contracted heart and great vessels, and pale kidneys with a congested medulla |
| Shock | Primary (neurogenic) shock — instantaneous death from vagal inhibition, severe pain or fright, with a negative autopsy; and secondary (hypovolaemic or septic) shock, developing over hours with a recognisable clinical course |
| Injury to a vital organ | Brain and brain stem; heart and great vessels; and injuries incompatible with life such as decapitation or crushing of the head. Death is instantaneous and no other explanation is needed |
| Asphyxia (mechanical) | Obstruction of the airway; aspiration OF blood, classically after facial and neck injury, and easily overlooked; tension pneumothorax; flail chest; and injury to the cervical cord above C4 |
| Air embolism | Air drawn into open veins under negative pressure — wounds of the neck and great veins, criminal abortion, neurosurgery in the sitting position, and childbirth. About 100 mL is rapidly fatal. Demonstrated at autopsy by the underwater (Ackerman) test, opening the heart under water to look for escaping bubbles — and the chest must be opened carefully to avoid producing artefactual air |
| Fat and other embolism | See below |
CLINICAL PEARL
Concealed internal haemorrhage kills patients who look uninjured. A ruptured spleen, a torn liver, a retroperitoneal bleed from a pelvic fracture or a closed femoral fracture can each hold a litre or more with no external bruise at all, particularly where the blow fell on the lax abdominal wall or the back. Pallor with absent lividity at autopsy, or an unexplained falling blood pressure in the living, is the finding — not the appearance of the skin.
Delayed Causes
| Cause | Typical interval and features |
|---|---|
| Infection | The commonest delayed cause — wound sepsis, septicaemia, peritonitis, meningitis after skull fracture, bronchopneumonia in the bedbound, gas gangrene (Clostridium perfringens, from soil-contaminated wounds), and tetanus, which remains important in India after trivial wounds and has an incubation of 4 to 21 days |
| Fat embolism | 1 to 3 days after fracture of a long bone (especially the femur) or extensive soft-tissue injury or burns. Presents with dyspnoea, confusion and a petechial rash on the chest, axillae and conjunctivae. Demonstrated by fat globules in the pulmonary vessels on frozen section with OSMIC acid or SUDAN stains — which requires frozen sections, since routine processing dissolves the fat away |
| Pulmonary thromboembolism | 1 to 3 weeks after injury or surgery, from deep vein thrombosis in an immobilised limb. A thrombus is distinguished from a postmortem clot by being firm, dry, granular, laminated (lines of Zahn) and adherent to the wall; a postmortem clot is soft, shiny, rubbery, "chicken fat and redcurrant jelly", and not adherent |
| Acute renal failure | From crush syndrome — myoglobin released from crushed muscle, with hyperkalaemia and acidosis; from prolonged hypotension; or from sepsis |
| ARDS and multi-organ failure | Days after major trauma, transfusion or sepsis |
| Complications of treatment | Anaesthetic and surgical complications, transfusion reaction, drug reaction — which do not break the chain of causation unless grossly negligent and independent |
| Late sequelae | Post-traumatic epilepsy; chronic subdural haematoma presenting weeks after a trivial head injury in the elderly or alcoholic; and suicide following disfigurement or disability |
Legal Position and Applied Aspects
- The assailant remains liable where the injury was the proximate cause, however long the interval, and this holds even where the victim had a pre-existing condition that made them unusually vulnerable, or where the treatment was imperfect. The law takes the victim as it finds them — the "eggshell skull" rule
- Only a genuinely independent intervening cause breaks the chain; ordinary complications of the injury and its treatment do not
- Explanation 2 to BNS 100 (formerly IPC 299) makes this explicit — where death is caused by a bodily injury, the person who caused the injury is deemed to have caused the death although proper treatment might have saved the victim
- Take frozen sections with a fat stain where fat embolism is suspected; routine paraffin processing dissolves the fat and the diagnosis is lost permanently
- Open the heart under water where air embolism is possible, before anything else is disturbed, and open the chest with care to avoid introducing air artefactually
- Distinguish thrombus from postmortem clot by adherence and lamination; reporting a postmortem clot as an embolus invents a cause of death
- Look for concealed haemorrhage in every trauma death — the chest, abdomen, retroperitoneum, pelvis and thighs — and measure the volume in each cavity rather than describing it
- Consider tetanus and gas gangrene in a delayed death after a contaminated wound in India; both are preventable, and their occurrence raises a separate question of the adequacy of the initial treatment
All questions in Mechanical Injuries
- Q1Define injury and hurt. Classify mechanical injuries and describe grievous hurt with the relevant legal provisions. ★
- Q2Describe abrasions and contusions with their types, ageing and medicolegal importance. ★
- Q3Describe lacerated, incised and stab wounds and distinguish between them. ★
- Q4Describe firearm injuries with the features of entry and exit wounds and the estimation of range. ★
- Q5Describe the medicolegal examination of wounds — antemortem and postmortem, ageing, manner of infliction and causes of death. ★
- SN1Describe defence wounds and hesitation cuts with their medicolegal importance. ★
- SN2Describe explosion and blast injuries. ★
- SN3Describe the injuries in road traffic accidents in pedestrians and vehicle occupants. ★
- SN4Describe the immediate and delayed causes of death from wounds. ★
- SN5Describe the medicolegal aspects of torture and custodial injuries. ★
- SN6Describe the injuries sustained in a fall from a height. ★
- SN7Describe the healing of wounds and the determination of the age of an injury.