Q3
LONG ANSWER
10M
★ High-yield
Define adverse drug reaction. Classify adverse drug reactions and describe their mechanisms. Add a note on pharmacovigilance.
Definitions
The WHO defines an adverse drug reaction as any noxious, unintended response to a drug occurring at doses normally used in man for prophylaxis, diagnosis or therapy.
- An adverse event is any untoward occurrence during treatment, whether or not it is caused by the drug — the distinction matters in trials and in causality assessment
- Doses "normally used in man" excludes deliberate overdose and poisoning
- Adverse reactions cause about 5% of hospital admissions and are a leading cause of iatrogenic death
Rawlins–thompson Classification
| Type | Name | Features | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type A | Augmented (pharmacological) | Predictable from the known action; dose-related; common (about 80%); low mortality; managed by reducing the dose | Bleeding with warfarin; hypoglycaemia with insulin; bradycardia with propranolol; dry mouth with atropine; postural hypotension with prazosin |
| Type B | Bizarre (idiosyncratic) | Unpredictable; not dose-related; uncommon; high mortality; managed by stopping the drug | Penicillin anaphylaxis; chloramphenicol aplastic anaemia; halothane hepatitis; malignant hyperthermia; Stevens–Johnson syndrome |
| Type C | Chronic (continuous) | Related to cumulative dose and duration | Osteoporosis and adrenal suppression with steroids; analgesic nephropathy; tardive dyskinesia; chloroquine retinopathy |
| Type D | Delayed | Appear long after exposure, sometimes in the next generation | Teratogenesis (thalidomide); carcinogenesis (vaginal adenocarcinoma in daughters exposed to diethylstilboestrol); second malignancy after alkylating agents |
| Type E | End of treatment (withdrawal) | Occur on stopping the drug | Rebound angina and infarction after abrupt beta-blocker withdrawal; adrenal crisis after stopping steroids; withdrawal seizures after benzodiazepines; hypertensive crisis after clonidine |
| Type F | Failure of therapy | Unexpected lack of efficacy, often from an interaction | Oral contraceptive failure with rifampicin or an antiepileptic |
CLINICAL PEARL
Types A and B differ in every practical respect, and the management follows from the difference. A type A reaction is an extension of the drug’s known action, so it is predictable and the answer is to reduce the dose. A type B reaction has nothing to do with the pharmacology, so no dose is safe and the drug must be stopped and never given again.
Types of Adverse Reaction BY Mechanism
| Category | Definition | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Side effect | An unwanted but pharmacologically predictable effect at therapeutic dose | Atropine causing dry mouth; morphine causing constipation |
| Secondary effect | An indirect consequence of the primary action | Superinfection and pseudomembranous colitis after broad-spectrum antibiotics; hypokalaemia from a diuretic precipitating digoxin toxicity |
| Toxic effect | Result of excessive dose or prolonged use | Aminoglycoside ototoxicity; paracetamol hepatotoxicity |
| Intolerance | A characteristic effect at an unusually low dose | Tinnitus after a single tablet of aspirin |
| Idiosyncrasy | A genetically determined abnormal response | Haemolysis with primaquine in G6PD deficiency; prolonged apnoea after succinylcholine with atypical pseudocholinesterase; malignant hyperthermia |
| Drug allergy (hypersensitivity) | Immunologically mediated; requires prior sensitisation; unrelated to dose | See below |
| Photosensitivity | Cutaneous reaction on exposure to light | Tetracyclines, sulphonamides, fluoroquinolones, amiodarone |
| Drug dependence | Psychological or physical | Opioids, benzodiazepines, alcohol, nicotine |
| Iatrogenic disease | Physician-induced disease | Steroid-induced Cushing syndrome; drug-induced parkinsonism |
Drug Allergy
| Gell and Coombs type | Mechanism | Timing | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type I | IgE on mast cells | Minutes | Anaphylaxis, urticaria, bronchospasm, angio-oedema — penicillin is the commonest cause |
| Type II | IgG or IgM against cell-bound antigen | Variable | Haemolytic anaemia (methyldopa, penicillin); thrombocytopenia (quinine, heparin); agranulocytosis |
| Type III | Immune complexes | 7–12 days | Serum sickness; drug-induced lupus (hydralazine, procainamide, isoniazid); vasculitis |
| Type IV | T cell mediated | 24–72 hours or longer | Contact dermatitis; maculopapular rashes; stevens–johnson syndrome and toxic epidermal necrolysis |
- Severe cutaneous reactions — Stevens–Johnson syndrome and toxic epidermal necrolysis are most often caused by sulphonamides, allopurinol, carbamazepine, phenytoin, lamotrigine, nevirapine and NSAIDs; mortality in toxic epidermal necrolysis exceeds 30%
- HLA-B*15:02 predicts carbamazepine-induced Stevens–Johnson syndrome in South-East Asian populations, and testing is recommended before starting it
Causality Assessment and Reporting
- WHO causality categories — certain, probable, possible, unlikely, conditional, unassessable; the Naranjo scale is a structured scoring system
- The strongest evidence is DE-challenge (improvement on stopping) and RE-challenge (recurrence on restarting) — though deliberate re-challenge is rarely ethical
- Pharmacovigilance is the science of detecting, assessing and preventing adverse effects; India runs the Pharmacovigilance Programme of India (PvPI)
- Spontaneous reporting (the yellow card system) is the main method of detecting rare type B reactions, because clinical trials are far too small to find an event occurring in 1 in 10,000 patients
- Under-reporting is the chief weakness — probably under 10% of reactions are reported; every clinician has a duty to report
Organ-specific Drug Toxicity
| Organ | Drugs and effect |
|---|---|
| Liver | Paracetamol (dose-related necrosis), isoniazid, rifampicin, pyrazinamide, methotrexate, halothane, valproate, amiodarone, statins |
| Kidney | Aminoglycosides, NSAIDs, ACE inhibitors, amphotericin B, contrast media, ciclosporin, cisplatin |
| Ear (ototoxicity) | Aminoglycosides (vestibular with streptomycin and gentamicin, cochlear with amikacin and kanamycin), loop diuretics, quinine, cisplatin, high-dose salicylates |
| Bone marrow | Chloramphenicol (aplastic anaemia), cytotoxics, carbimazole and clozapine (agranulocytosis), phenytoin, co-trimoxazole, zidovudine |
| Eye | Ethambutol (optic neuritis and loss of colour vision), chloroquine (retinopathy), steroids (cataract and glaucoma), amiodarone (corneal deposits) |
| Nerve | Isoniazid, vincristine, metronidazole, nitrofurantoin, phenytoin (peripheral neuropathy) |
| Heart | Doxorubicin (dose-related cardiomyopathy), drugs prolonging the QT interval — quinidine, sotalol, erythromycin, antipsychotics — causing torsades DE pointes |
| Lung | Amiodarone, bleomycin, methotrexate, nitrofurantoin (pulmonary fibrosis) |
Applied Aspects
- Prevention — take a careful drug and allergy history, avoid unnecessary polypharmacy, start low and go slow in the elderly, adjust for renal and hepatic function, and anticipate interactions
- Always ask what happened when a patient reports an "allergy" — most reported penicillin allergy is nausea or a non-specific rash, and wrongly labelling a patient allergic denies them the best treatment for life
- Type B reactions cannot be predicted but can be recognised early — warn patients on carbimazole or clozapine to report a sore throat, and on antiepileptics to report a rash
- Stop the offending drug and record the reaction prominently; the record is what protects the patient at the next admission
- Post-marketing surveillance found the problem in every famous drug withdrawal — thalidomide, practolol, rofecoxib, cerivastatin — because none was detectable in pre-marketing trials
- In India, self-medication and over-the-counter sale of prescription drugs are widespread, and a drug history must ask specifically about them rather than relying on what is volunteered
All questions in General Pharmacology: Pharmacodynamics
- Q1Describe the mechanisms of drug action. Classify receptors and describe their signal transduction mechanisms. ★
- Q2Describe the dose-response relationship. Explain potency, efficacy, agonists, antagonists and the therapeutic index. ★
- Q3Define adverse drug reaction. Classify adverse drug reactions and describe their mechanisms. Add a note on pharmacovigilance. ★
- Q4Describe the factors modifying drug action and dosage. Add a note on tolerance and the placebo effect. ★
- Q5Describe the stages of drug development and the phases of clinical trial. Explain the essential features of a good clinical trial. ★
- SN1Define therapeutic index. Explain its significance with examples. ★
- SN2Define partial agonist and inverse agonist. Give examples and their clinical significance. ★
- SN3Define tolerance and tachyphylaxis. Describe their mechanisms with examples. ★
- SN4Classify drug antagonism with examples. Add a note on synergism. ★
- SN5Define teratogenicity. Describe the critical periods and the important teratogenic drugs. ★
- SN6Define essential medicines. Describe the criteria for selection and the principles of rational prescribing. ★
- SN7Describe the placebo effect with its mechanisms, uses and ethical considerations.