Describe the tuberculin (Mantoux) test with its principle, interpretation and limitations.
Principle and Technique
The tuberculin (mantoux) test is a type IV delayed hypersensitivity reaction demonstrating previous sensitisation to mycobacterial antigen — that is, infection, not disease.
0.1 mL of PPD (purified protein derivative) containing 5 tuberculin units is injected intradermally into the flexor surface of the forearm → A correct injection raises a pale wheal of 6 to 10 mm; if no wheal forms the injection was subcutaneous and must be repeated elsewhere → Sensitised T lymphocytes recognise the antigen and release cytokines → Macrophages and lymphocytes accumulate over the following hours → Read at 48 to 72 hours → Measure the transverse diameter of induration, not of erythema, by palpation or the ballpoint pen method
| Induration | Interpreted as positive in |
|---|---|
| ≥ 5 mm | HIV infection; close contacts of a sputum-positive case; those on immunosuppressive therapy or steroids; organ transplant recipients; fibrotic changes on chest radiograph |
| ≥ 10 mm | Children under 4; recent immigrants from high-prevalence countries; injecting drug users; healthcare workers; diabetes, chronic kidney disease, malignancy, malnutrition; residents of congregate settings |
| ≥ 15 mm | Persons with NO risk factors at all |
CLINICAL PEARL
The test measures whether the immune system has met the organism, which is not the same as whether the patient has the disease. A positive result in India, where BCG is universal and background infection is high, is expected in a large part of the healthy population. And a negative result carries little reassurance in exactly the patients most at risk, because severe disease itself suppresses the response. The test is therefore weak in both directions, and cannot stand alone.
Causes of False Results
- False positive — previous BCG vaccination (though the effect wanes over years); infection with non-tuberculous mycobacteria; incorrect reading of erythema instead of induration; and the booster phenomenon, in which a first test restimulates waning immunity so that a second test weeks later appears larger and is misread as recent conversion
- False negative (anergy) — overwhelming tuberculosis itself, particularly miliary disease and tuberculous meningitis; HIV and other immunosuppression; corticosteroids and cytotoxic drugs; malnutrition; measles, chickenpox and other viral infections and live viral vaccination within 6 weeks; sarcoidosis, lymphoma; extremes of age; and the window period of 4 to 6 weeks after infection before hypersensitivity develops
- Technical errors — subcutaneous injection, deteriorated or improperly stored PPD, and reading at the wrong time
Uses and Limitations
- Uses — supporting a diagnosis of tuberculosis in children (where it carries more weight than in adults); detecting latent infection before immunosuppressive or anti-TNF therapy, before transplantation and in contacts; epidemiological surveys of infection prevalence; and assessing cell-mediated immunity
- Limitations — it cannot distinguish latent infection from active disease, nor recent from remote infection; it is confounded by BCG and environmental mycobacteria; it requires two visits; and reading is subjective
- Interferon-gamma release assays use ESAT-6 and CFP-10, antigens absent from BCG, so they are not confounded by vaccination, require only one visit and are objective — but they are expensive and equally unable to separate latent from active disease
- A strongly positive test in a young child is more meaningful, since it suggests recent infection and a real risk of progression, which is why contact tracing in children is worthwhile
Applied Aspects
- Never diagnose or exclude tuberculosis on this test alone — it supports a clinical diagnosis and nothing more
- Measure induration by palpation, not erythema; reading redness is the commonest technical error and consistently overcalls the result
- A negative test in a very ill patient may indicate anergy rather than absence of infection, and this is exactly the situation in which the disease is most dangerous
- Its value is limited in India by universal BCG and a high prevalence of infection, which is why the national programme relies on bacteriological confirmation rather than on tuberculin testing
- Use it to screen for latent infection before anti-TNF therapy, transplantation or prolonged steroids, where identifying and treating latent tuberculosis prevents a potentially fatal reactivation
- Store PPD correctly and use it promptly; it is light-sensitive and adsorbs to glass and plastic, and deteriorated antigen gives false negatives
- A single test result cannot be compared with one done elsewhere unless the same antigen strength and reading method were used; conversion should be judged on tests performed under comparable conditions
- Treat latent infection where it is identified before immunosuppression, usually with isoniazid or a rifamycin-based regimen; identifying it and doing nothing wastes the test
All questions in Mycobacteria & Spirochaetes
- Q1Describe Mycobacterium tuberculosis with its morphology, cultural characteristics and the pathogenesis of primary and post-primary tuberculosis. ★
- Q2Describe the laboratory diagnosis of tuberculosis including microscopy, culture and the newer molecular methods. ★
- Q3Describe Mycobacterium leprae and the classification, diagnosis and treatment of leprosy. ★
- Q4Describe Treponema pallidum and the stages, serological diagnosis and treatment of syphilis. ★
- Q5Classify the spirochaetes. Describe Borrelia and the non-venereal treponematoses. ★
- SN1Classify the non-tuberculous mycobacteria. Describe their clinical importance. ★
- SN2Describe the tuberculin (Mantoux) test with its principle, interpretation and limitations. ★
- SN3Describe the BCG vaccine with its preparation, administration, efficacy and adverse effects. ★
- SN4Define MDR and XDR tuberculosis. Describe how resistance arises and its diagnosis and treatment. ★
- SN5Describe the lepra reactions with their types, features and management. ★
- SN6Describe leptospirosis with its epidemiology, clinical features, diagnosis and treatment. ★
- SN7Describe the forms of extrapulmonary tuberculosis with their diagnosis and treatment.