SN5 SHORT NOTE 5M ★ High-yield

Describe the medicolegal aspects of the MTP Act, the PC-PNDT Act and assisted reproduction.

Forensic Medicine · 2nd Professional — Para-Clinical

The Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act

The MTP Act 1971, substantially amended in 2021, permits termination in defined circumstances. Its purpose was to reduce the deaths from unsafe illegal abortion, which were very large before it
Grounds — risk to the life of the pregnant woman or grave injury to her physical or mental health; substantial risk of serious fetal abnormality; pregnancy resulting from rape (the anguish being presumed to constitute grave injury to mental health); and failure OF contraception — which after the 2021 amendment applies to any woman and her partner, not only to a married couple

Gestation	Requirement (post-2021)
Up to 20 weeks	The opinion of one registered medical practitioner
20 to 24 weeks	The opinion of two registered medical practitioners, for specified categories of women — survivors of rape or incest, minors, women whose marital status changed during pregnancy, women with disability, mentally ill women, cases of fetal abnormality, and women in humanitarian or disaster settings
Beyond 24 weeks	Only for substantial fetal abnormality, and only on the opinion of a state-level medical board constituted under the Act
Any stage	Termination is permitted without these limits where it is immediately necessary to save the woman'S life
Consent	The woman'S own consent alone. The husband'S consent is not required. A guardian consents for a minor under 18 or a mentally ill woman
Confidentiality	The 2021 amendment makes it an offence to reveal the identity of a woman who has undergone termination, except to a person authorised by law

Termination may be performed only by a doctor with the prescribed training and experience, at an approved place; doing it otherwise is an offence under the Act and under BNS, irrespective of the outcome
The POCSO overlap — a pregnancy in a girl under 18 implies a sexual offence, and reporting to the police is mandatory under POCSO. Courts have clarified that this does not prevent termination, and that the girl's identity is protected, but the reporting obligation is absolute

CLINICAL PEARL

The husband’s consent is not required for termination or sterilisation, and asking for it is unlawful. This is settled and unambiguous, yet consent forms in many Indian hospitals still carry a space for the husband’s signature, and women are turned away without it. A doctor who refuses a lawful termination for want of a husband’s consent is denying a statutory right and exposing the woman to exactly the unsafe alternative the Act exists to prevent.

The PC-PNDT Act

The pre-conception and pre-natal diagnostic techniques (prohibition OF sex selection) act 1994, amended in 2003, exists to address the declining child sex ratio caused by sex-selective abortion
It prohibits — sex determination or disclosure of the sex of the fetus by any means, to anyone, including the pregnant woman herself; advertising sex determination or pre-conception sex selection; and sex selection before or after conception
It regulates — registration of every genetic counselling centre, laboratory and clinic; maintenance of form F for every ultrasound performed on a pregnant woman, retained for two years; and display of a notice stating that sex determination is not done there
Prenatal diagnosis is permitted only for detecting specified abnormalities — chromosomal, genetic, metabolic, haemoglobinopathies and congenital malformations — and only on specified indications such as maternal age above 35 or a family history
Penalties — imprisonment up to 3 years and fine for a first offence, rising for a subsequent one, for both the doctor and the person seeking it; and suspension of registration by the medical council on the mere framing of charges, which is unusually severe and deliberate
The Act is one of the few in which the burden OF proof is effectively reversed in some respects, and in which meticulous record-keeping is itself the principal defence — a doctor with incomplete Form F records is in difficulty regardless of what they actually did

Assisted Reproduction and Applied Aspects

The assisted reproductive technology (regulation) act 2021 and the surrogacy (regulation) act 2021 regulate ART clinics and banks, establish a national registry, set standards for gamete donation and storage, and prohibit commercial surrogacy, permitting only altruistic surrogacy for defined categories of intending couples
Ethical issues in ART — the status and disposal of surplus embryos; multiple pregnancy from transferring several embryos, and selective reduction; donor anonymity against the child's interest in knowing their origin; exploitation of poor women as surrogates and donors, which is why commercial surrogacy was banned; and access, since ART is largely unaffordable
Do not disclose fetal sex, in any manner, to anyone; indirect indications — a phrase, a gesture, the colour of a sweet — have been prosecuted, and the prohibition is absolute
Complete Form F for every obstetric ultrasound and retain it; the commonest ground on which radiologists are prosecuted under PC-PNDT is not sex determination but incomplete records
Do not require the husband's consent for termination or sterilisation, and remove it from your consent forms if it is there
Report a pregnancy in a girl under 18 under POCSO; this is mandatory and non-reporting is itself an offence, but termination is not prevented by it and the girl's identity remains protected

All questions in Medical Ethics, Consent & Negligence

Every Forensic Medicine chapter →