Describe the chronic respiratory diseases of public health importance.
Chronic Respiratory Disease
Chronic respiratory diseases — principally chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and asthma — are among the leading causes of death and disability in India. Their distinctive feature here is that a large share of the burden is caused by exposures other than cigarette smoking, which is why the Western model fits India poorly.
- COPD is characterised by persistent, largely irreversible airflow limitation, and encompasses chronic bronchitis and emphysema
- The risk factors in the Indian context:
- Tobacco smoking, particularly bidi smoking, remains the largest single cause
- Indoor air pollution from biomass fuel — wood, dung and crop residue — burnt in unventilated kitchens, which is a major cause of COPD in rural INDIAN women who have never smoked
- That group is the reason the Western smoking-centred model misleads in India, and it should be named explicitly in any answer
- Outdoor air pollution, with several Indian cities among the most polluted in the world
- Occupational dust and fumes — mining, textiles, construction and agriculture
- Childhood respiratory infection and impaired lung growth, and past tuberculosis, which leaves a substantial obstructive deficit and is an important and specifically Indian contributor
- Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency, which is rare
- Diagnosis requires spirometry, showing a post-bronchodilator FEV1/FVC ratio below 0.70; COPD is substantially under-diagnosed because spirometry is rarely available at primary level
- Prevention and control — tobacco cessation, which is the only intervention that alters the rate of decline in lung function; clean cooking fuel, which is the key population measure in rural India and is the rationale for the LPG access programme; improved kitchen ventilation and chimney stoves where LPG is not available; occupational dust control; ambient air quality regulation; and influenza and pneumococcal vaccination
- Management — inhaled bronchodilators as the mainstay, with pulmonary rehabilitation, which is effective, cheap and almost entirely unavailable in India, and oxygen for chronic hypoxaemia
- Asthma is a chronic inflammatory airway disease with variable and largely reversible airflow obstruction
- Its triggers — allergens (dust mite, pollen, animal dander, cockroach), respiratory infection, exercise, cold air, smoke, air pollution, occupational agents, drugs including aspirin and beta-blockers, and emotion
- The central problem in India is under-treatment, and it has three causes — under-diagnosis; steroid phobia, both among patients and among prescribers; and a widespread belief that inhalers are a last resort or addictive, so oral medication is preferred
- The correct message is the opposite — inhaled therapy delivers a far smaller dose directly to the airway with fewer systemic effects than tablets, and inhaled corticosteroids are the controller that prevents attacks and deaths
- Reliever medication used frequently indicates poor control and the need for a controller, not for more reliever
- Practical management points — teach and check inhaler technique at every visit, since most patients use it incorrectly; use a spacer, which improves delivery and can be improvised cheaply; provide a written asthma action plan; identify and avoid triggers; and treat the smoking, obesity and rhinitis that worsen control
- Asthma deaths are almost always preventable, and typically follow under-use of controller therapy, over-reliance on reliever, and failure to recognise deterioration
- Biomass smoke causes COPD in women who never smoked, which is why the Western smoking-centred model misleads in India
- Clean cooking fuel is a respiratory intervention, which is the public health rationale for LPG access programmes
- Inhaled therapy gives less drug with fewer effects than tablets, which is the opposite of what patients assume
- Frequent reliever use means poor control, and calls for a controller rather than more reliever
- Check inhaler technique at every visit, since most patients use the device incorrectly
- A spacer improves delivery and can be improvised cheaply, which matters where devices are unaffordable
- Steroid phobia affects prescribers too, not only patients, and is a major cause of under-treatment
- Asthma deaths are almost always preventable, following under-use of controllers and failure to recognise deterioration
- Past tuberculosis leaves obstructive deficit, which is an important and specifically Indian contributor to COPD
- Spirometry is needed for diagnosis and is rarely available, which is why COPD is substantially under-diagnosed
- Only cessation alters the rate of decline in lung function, whatever else is prescribed
- Pulmonary rehabilitation is effective and unavailable, being cheap and almost entirely absent from Indian services
- Give a written action plan, which improves outcomes and costs nothing beyond the consultation time
CLINICAL PEARL
COPD in a rural Indian woman who has never smoked is a biomass problem, not a tobacco one. Unventilated cooking with wood and dung is a major cause here, which is why clean cooking fuel is a respiratory intervention. And in asthma, correct the belief that inhalers are a last resort: inhaled therapy gives a smaller dose with fewer systemic effects than tablets, and frequent reliever use means the controller is inadequate.
All questions in Non-communicable Disease Epidemiology
- Q1Describe the epidemiology and prevention of non-communicable diseases. ★
- Q2Describe the epidemiology and prevention of cardiovascular disease and hypertension. ★
- Q3Describe the epidemiology, prevention and control of diabetes mellitus. ★
- Q4Describe cancer epidemiology and the principles of cancer control in India. ★
- Q5Discuss tobacco and alcohol as public health problems and their control. ★
- SN1Describe obesity and the metabolic syndrome. ★
- SN2Describe the chronic respiratory diseases of public health importance. ★
- SN3Discuss mental health as a public health problem. ★
- SN4Describe the epidemiology and prevention of road traffic injuries. ★
- SN5Describe the health problems of the elderly and their care. ★
- SN6Describe disability and the principles of rehabilitation. ★
- SN7Describe rheumatic fever and rheumatic heart disease as a public health problem.