Describe the spacing methods of contraception.
Barrier and Hormonal Methods
Spacing (temporary) methods allow a couple to delay or space births while preserving future fertility. Their importance in India is that the programme has historically been dominated by sterilisation, so young couples wanting to space rather than stop have been the least well served — which is where the unmet need is concentrated.
- Barrier methods:
- The condom (Nirodh) — the only method that also protects against sexually transmitted infection and HIV, which is its decisive advantage and the reason for dual protection, meaning a condom used alongside another method
- It is cheap, safe, has no systemic effects, requires no medical supervision, and involves the male partner; but is use-dependent, so its typical-use failure is considerably higher than its perfect-use failure, and it requires consistent motivation at every act
- The female condom, diaphragm and cervical cap are female-controlled but little used in India; spermicides alone are unreliable
- Intrauterine devices:
- The copper T 380A is effective for 10 years and the Cu 375 for 5 years; LNG-IUS releases levonorgestrel and additionally reduces menstrual bleeding
- Its mechanism — copper is spermicidal and impairs sperm motility and viability, with a foreign-body inflammatory reaction in the endometrium; it acts chiefly by preventing fertilisation rather than by preventing implantation, which is worth knowing since the belief that it is abortifacient is a common reason for refusal
- Its advantages — highly effective; long-acting and reversible; requires a single act of motivation rather than daily compliance; cost-effective; no systemic hormonal effect with copper; and immediately reversible on removal
- Its disadvantages — increased menstrual bleeding and cramping, which is the commonest reason for removal and matters greatly in an anaemic population; expulsion, particularly in the first year; perforation, which is rare and related to insertion technique; increased risk of pelvic infection in the first 20 days after insertion only; and if pregnancy occurs, a higher proportion is ectopic
- That last point requires care — the IUCD reduces the absolute risk of ectopic pregnancy compared with using no method, because it prevents pregnancy overall; it is only the proportion of the few pregnancies that occur which is higher
- Contraindications — known or suspected pregnancy; active pelvic infection; undiagnosed abnormal uterine bleeding; distorted uterine cavity; and genital malignancy
- Postpartum IUCD insertion may be done within 48 hours of delivery or after 6 weeks, and is promoted in India because it uses the institutional delivery contact
- Hormonal methods:
- Combined oral contraceptives (Mala-N, Mala-D) — containing oestrogen and progestogen, acting chiefly by suppressing ovulation, with thickened cervical mucus and endometrial change
- Their non-contraceptive benefits should be mentioned, since they are substantial and frequently forgotten — regular, lighter and less painful periods; reduced iron deficiency anaemia; and reduced risk of ovarian and endometrial cancer, ovarian cysts, benign breast disease and pelvic inflammatory disease
- Their risks — venous thromboembolism, the most important; raised blood pressure; a small increase in stroke and myocardial infarction, particularly in smokers over 35; and nausea, breast tenderness and breakthrough bleeding
- The absolute contraindications — smoking over the age of 35; history of thromboembolism; ischaemic heart disease or stroke; migraine with aura; uncontrolled hypertension; active liver disease; breast cancer; and breastfeeding in the early postpartum period
Progestogen-only Methods, Natural Methods and Counselling
- Progestogen-only pills — acting chiefly by thickening cervical mucus; their key advantage is that they are safe in breastfeeding and in women in whom oestrogen is contraindicated; but they require strict daily timing
- Injectable contraceptives — DMPA (Antara programme) given 3-monthly
- Their advantages — highly effective, long-acting, private (requiring no visible supplies at home), safe in breastfeeding, and independent of intercourse
- The privacy point matters in the Indian context, since it allows a woman to use contraception without her family knowing
- Their disadvantages — menstrual irregularity progressing to amenorrhoea, which is the commonest reason for discontinuation and must be explained in advance; delayed return of fertility, of several months, which makes them unsuitable for a couple wanting to conceive soon; weight gain; and reversible loss of bone density
- Counselling that amenorrhoea is expected and harmless is what determines whether a woman continues, and its omission is the commonest programme failure with this method
- Implants — subdermal, effective for 3 to 5 years; centchroman (Ormeloxifene, Chhaya) — a non-hormonal, non-steroidal weekly pill developed in India, taken twice weekly for 3 months then weekly, which is safe in breastfeeding
- Natural and traditional methods:
- The calendar (rhythm) method, based on the fertile period; basal body temperature; cervical mucus (Billings) method; symptothermal method; and standard days with CycleBeads
- They have NO side effects and are acceptable where other methods are refused on religious grounds, but have high typical-use failure, require regular cycles, need considerable motivation and cooperation from both partners, and demand prolonged abstinence
- Withdrawal (coitus interruptus) — widely practised and better than nothing, but with high failure
- The lactational amenorrhoea method is effective only while all three conditions hold — infant under 6 months, breastfeeding fully or nearly exclusively day and night, and menses not returned
- The principles of contraceptive counselling, which is what an examiner most wants to see:
- There is NO single "best" method — the best method is the one the couple will use correctly and consistently
- Offer an informed choice from the full range, describing effectiveness, how it is used, side effects, non-contraceptive benefits, return of fertility and protection against infection
- Consider the couple’s age, parity, whether they want to space or to stop, breastfeeding status, medical conditions and their own preference
- Warn about the expected side effects IN advance, since an unexpected side effect causes discontinuation while an expected one usually does not — which is the single most useful practical rule in contraceptive counselling
- Explain what to do if a dose is missed, and provide follow-UP
- Distinguish perfect-use from typical-use failure honestly, since the gap between them is what actually determines outcomes in a programme, and it is widest for the methods requiring the most user action
- That reasoning is the argument for long-acting reversible contraception — the IUCD, implant and injectable have typical-use failure close to their perfect-use failure, because they do not depend on daily behaviour
- The best method is the one they will use, which is why counselling matters more than any ranking of effectiveness
- Warn about side effects in advance, since an expected one is tolerated and an unexpected one ends the method
- Typical use diverges most from perfect use in the methods needing daily action, which is the argument for long-acting methods
- Condoms are the only method preventing infection, which is the basis of dual protection alongside another method
- The IUCD prevents fertilisation, not implantation, which matters because the abortifacient belief causes refusal
- Heavier bleeding is why IUCDs are removed, and matters greatly in an already anaemic population
- Infection risk is confined to the first twenty days after insertion, not to the whole period of use
- The IUCD reduces absolute ectopic risk; only the proportion of the few pregnancies occurring is higher
- Combined pills reduce ovarian and endometrial cancer, alongside lighter periods and less anaemia
- Smoking over thirty-five contraindicates combined pills, which is the contraindication most often overlooked in practice
- Migraine with aura rules out combined pills, though migraine without aura generally does not
- Progestogen-only methods are safe in breastfeeding, unlike combined pills in the early postpartum period
- Injectables are private, needing nothing kept at home, which allows use without the family knowing
- Amenorrhoea on injectables is expected and harmless, and explaining that in advance determines whether she continues
- Injectables delay return of fertility by months, so they suit a couple who do not want to conceive soon
- Centchroman is non-hormonal and weekly, developed in India and safe during breastfeeding
- Postpartum IUCD uses the delivery contact, inserted within forty-eight hours or deferred to six weeks
- Natural methods demand cooperation from both, and prolonged abstinence, which is why typical-use failure is high
- Spacing is where the unmet need lies, since the programme has historically served those wanting to stop
- Explain what to do about a missed pill, which is a routine part of counselling and routinely omitted
- The copper T 380A lasts ten years, which makes it among the most cost-effective methods available
- LNG-IUS reduces bleeding rather than increasing it, which makes it suitable where menorrhagia is the concern
CLINICAL PEARL
The best method is the one the couple will actually use. There is no single best, and the gap between perfect-use and typical-use failure is widest for the methods needing the most user action — which is the real argument for long-acting reversible methods. And warn about side effects in advance: an expected side effect is tolerated, an unexpected one ends the method.
All questions in Demography and Family Planning
- Q1Describe demography and the demographic cycle with its application to India. ★
- Q2Discuss population growth in India with its determinants and consequences. ★
- Q3Describe the spacing methods of contraception. ★
- Q4Describe the terminal methods of contraception and emergency contraception. ★
- Q5Describe the national family planning programme and population policy of India. ★
- SN1Describe the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act. ★
- SN2Describe the census of India and its uses. ★
- SN3Describe the population pyramid and the age structure of a population. ★
- SN4Describe infertility with its causes and management. ★
- SN5Describe the evaluation of family planning services. ★
- SN6Discuss migration and urbanisation as determinants of health. ★
- SN7Discuss the ethical issues in family planning.